Mother’s Day: ‘Fake’ Holiday Pressure & How to Beat Guilt

Let me tell you a secret about Mother’s Day.

It’s not real.

It’s a made-up holiday invented by marketers — people like me — whose job is to make you feel guilty enough to spend money you weren’t planning to.

Don’t get me wrong. Moms deserve to be celebrated. But somewhere between handmade cards and $600 spa packages, Mother’s Day morphed into something else: a test. A test of how successful you are. A test of how grateful you appear. A test of whether you love her enough — and whether your love can be tallied up in dollars and cents.

And if you grew up with a mom who wasn’t shy about pointing out when you didn’t quite measure up? Well, you know the stakes feel even higher.

Today, you’ve (probably) outgrown your macaroni art phase. You’re a working adult — maybe a doctor, lawyer, executive — with an income to match. You can afford to spend now. But how much is enough?

When does thoughtful turn into performative? And how do you navigate the emotional minefield without blowing up your wallet — or your relationship?

Let’s talk about it.

First, a quick reality check: Mother’s Day is technically real.

There’s a whole Wikipedia page about it, if you want unimpeachable, hard pop science proof.

And it’s been a federally recognized holiday since 1914, when President Woodrow Wilson signed it into law, thanks to the tireless efforts of Anna Jarvis who, ironically, would later spend her entire life railing against the commercialization of the day she created.

The first Mother’s Day was about love, loss, and gratitude. It involved church services, carnations, and handwritten letters — not prix-fixe menus, spa bundles, flower subscription boxes, or “gift guides” designed to make you feel like a trash human if you didn’t shell out $200 or more.

In comparison to how we celebrate it now?

Pure commercialism, baby. I love opulence and decadence as much as the next Instagram-loving mom, but Mother’s Day, in its current form, has gotten a bit grotesque.

So if you’re feeling a little twitchy about how much is “enough” — especially now that you’re finally in a place to spend “real money” — you’re not alone.

Here are some ideas on how to honor your mom without letting capitalism (or old guilt) max out your AmEx.

Why Mother’s Day feels so loaded for high earners

If you’re doing well financially, especially if you’ve “made it” in a high-status field like medicine, law, or tech, Mother’s Day hits different.

You’re no longer scraping together change for a Whitman’s Sampler (from Walgreens) and hoping it passes for thoughtful. You’ve got options now — disposable income. A partner who tells you it’s time to level up your gift game.

And maybe you want to go big because you’re grateful, especially because your mom has sacrificed a lot to help pay for med school, babysitting your kids, or picking up the pieces when you were too burnt to function.

Or maybe she didn’t. Maybe your mom was more demanding than warm, and she lets you know your life choices have never quite measured up. Now, standing in the department store, you’re pawing a silk scarf and wonder if it can cover decades of emotional taxation.

Money and guilt are tricky things. Once you earn more money, people assume you have more money to spend, especially on the people who raised you. And if you don’t, because you choose to set boundaries or spend modestly, you’re labeled as ungrateful, cold, and stingy.

But here’s the truth: the size of your paycheck does not automatically dictate the size of your Mother’s Day gift. Your net worth doesn’t determine your love.

Thoughtful ≠ expensive

It’s easy to confuse meaning with monetary, especially when WE’ve been conditioned to believe that “real” gifts come from upscale stores, not the heart. Macaroni picture frames are fine for kids who don’t have money, but shouldn’t grown-ups spend grown-up money?

Not necessarily.

Let’s take a scientific sample size of one — me, I’m a mother of a six-year-old and four-year-old — and what I want would probably cost money. But more than that, I want time, presence, and connection.

I don’t need a gift card or a new Alexa device. (Although the latter might actually be kind of thoughtful because I love tech gadgets and my family knows it.)

I want to feel remembered, appreciated, and special – memorable experiences over silk scarves and pots of peonies.

Your mom might be the high-expectations type, I get it. Growing up, my mom was never the type to tell her kids she needed nothing and to keep their money, or that she needed more tube socks. No. She would ask me how much money I had to spend (even as a very young child), ask me how I reached that number (getting me to inch it upward), and then circle what she wanted from the weekly ads based on the upper end of my budget.

As a mom now, I kind of get it. My kids occasionally get money for birthdays or for helping their dad with chores. And they never want to part with any of it; they want to hoard it. I want them to learn a sense of generosity and selflessness.

But spending money isn’t the only way to demonstrate consideration. We’ve conflated cost with value, and many let the price tag do all the emotional heavy-lifting.

Gift-giving gut check

Here’s a gut check:

• Would this gift still feel thoughtful if you made $45K a year?
• Would you still give it if you weren’t trying to prove something?
• Would it make your mom feel seen, or just temporarily silenced?

If you can answer a resounding “yes” to any of these questions, you’re probably on the right track.

The best gifts aren’t about status. They’re about intentionality. A phone call without multitasking. A framed photo of a good day you spent together. A reservation somewhere, she doesn’t have to make the decisions. A handwritten note saying thank you for something specific.

If it comes from the heart – and not the clearance section at the airport gift shop — it counts.

Meaningful gift ideas (almost) any mom would love

If you’re stuck on what to give, here’s a secret: it’s not about the price. It’s about effort, memory, and meaning. (Although if you do happen to splurge a little, no one’s banning you from sainthood.)

Here are a few ideas that work for sentimental moms, fancy moms, practical moms — and even the occasionally impossible-to-please moms:

• Frame a photo she loves. Better yet, print out a stack of favorite family photos that have been trapped on your phone forever. Give them a real life in a frame or album she can flip through anytime.
• Plant something together. Pick out a tree, a rosebush, or a peony she loves — and spend the morning digging, planting, and watering as a family. It’s a gift that grows, just like her decades of unpaid labor raising you.
• Book a mini family photo session. Not the Olan Mills awkward pose kind — the relaxed, golden-hour kind. Something casual and real that freezes this season of life.
• Tackle a long-ignored project. Hang that mirror that’s been leaning against the basement wall for two years. Paint the hallway that’s been scuffed since your dog was a puppy. Do the thing she’s asked for…without her having to ask again.
• Take a class together. Pottery, cooking, watercolor painting — whatever feels fun and low-pressure. Bonus points if it ends with something edible or fridge-display-worthy.
• Plan a shared experience. A hot air balloon ride, a sunset sail, or a casual weekend getaway — even if you have to defer the date until the toddler years are behind you.
• Thoughtful jewelry, not flashy jewelry. A charm bracelet with your kids’ birth months, or a simple necklace that symbolizes family without screaming “this cost $4,000.”
• Late breakfast out. Sleep in, roll out of bed at 10, and head to her favorite diner, patio, or brunch spot. It’s the thought — and the no cooking — that counts.
• Groupon, but only if it’s good. If you find an amazing, personalized experience (like glass blowing lessons she’s mentioned wanting to try), cool. But if it screams “last-minute,” like 2-for-1 axe-throwing? Maybe rethink it.

How to handle a demanding mom (spouses included) without losing your mind

Maybe your mom expects something extravagant. Maybe your wife thinks you should “go bigger” because now you can. Either way, Mother’s Day shouldn’t feel like a hostage negotiation.

Here’s the reality: You don’t owe luxury.

If you owe anything, it’s love. But even some would argue you don’t need to trot it out, performatively, for a Hallmark holiday.

If your mom circles (metaphorically or otherwise) what she wants on catalogs, based on your bank balance, you need to decide in advance:

• What you’re willing to give
• What you’re not willing to give
• And how much peace you’re willing to trade for the price of admission

The same goes if your spouse thinks the only acceptable gift is a designer bag or a Caribbean cruise. A rosebush planted with your kids, a mini family photo session, or a meal shared without screens? Those are gifts of presence, and are priceless if you frame them right.

It’s OK to give something generous — if it doesn’t harm your present-day or long-term financial wellness goals.

It’s also OK to set a boundary.

Pick something that feels good to give, something that feels like love, not obligation.
Then let go of managing how it’s received.

If your mom or spouse responds with gratitude, awesome. If they respond with guilt trips, sighs, or martyrdom? That’s information about them, not you.

The bottom line (because, of course, there’s a bottom line)

Mother’s Day isn’t about spending extravagantly. It’s not a competition, a report card, or a guilt trip unless you let it become one.

It’s a chance to make someone feel appreciated, and you don’t have to overindulge to do that.

A well-timed phone call. A handwritten note. A rosebush, planted together. A meal where no one has to do dishes. That’s the kind of presence no gift receipt can buy.

So whether you’re navigating high expectations, a complicated relationship, or just the crushing weight of targeted Instagram ads, take a breath. Step back. Spend with intention, not anxiety.

And if anyone makes you feel like you didn’t do enough? You can always send them an expired Groupon:

Fundrise - Venture Portfolio