The Physician’s Holiday: Working While Others Celebrate

December looks different when you’re covering a hospital shift.

While most Americans debate whether to spend 10% more or less on gifts this year, many physicians face a more fundamental question: will they see their families at all? The holiday season that dominates consumer surveys and retail forecasts exists in a parallel universe to the one experienced in hospitals and clinics across the country.

You might think physicians are sad about missing a party, but that’s not quite it. Physicians are expected to sacrifice holidays, often without adequate compensation or support, while hospital administrators enjoy their paid time off.

Also read: The Two Americas of Holiday Spending

The Holiday Shift Reality

Most people’s holiday stress centers on dealing with difficult relatives or managing tight budgets. Physicians often don’t get that luxury. The stress comes from not being there at all.

Emergency departments don’t close for Christmas. Neither do ICUs nor labor and delivery units. Someone has to staff them. That someone is frequently a physician who drew the short straw in scheduling, took the shift because locums pay rates make it worth the sacrifice, or simply couldn’t say no when administration made it clear the hospital needed coverage.

The work doesn’t pause for the calendar. If anything, it intensifies. Holiday weekends bring their own surge of patients. Trauma from car accidents on icy roads. Heart attacks triggered by holiday stress and heavy meals.

Exacerbations of chronic conditions in patients who skipped appointments or medications while traveling.

You can’t half-work these shifts. A patient coding at 3 pm on Christmas Eve requires the same focused attention as one coding on a Tuesday in March. The pager doesn’t care about family dinner plans. Neither does the attending who needs a consult. Neither does the ER physician calling about a patient who needs admission.

Don’t miss: Wicked Is The Yellow Brick Road to Retirement

The Financial Calculus

For some physicians, particularly those carrying six-figure student loan balances, holiday shifts represent an opportunity. Locums rates can be substantially higher during holidays when regular staff understandably want time off.

The calculation becomes straightforward: work Christmas, pay down another chunk of debt.

This creates a perverse incentive structure. The physicians most burdened by educational debt are the ones most likely to volunteer for holiday coverage, not because they want to miss Christmas morning with their kids, but because they need the money.

Meanwhile, more established physicians with paid-off loans can afford to protect their time off.

The problem compounds for those without proper paid time off. Some employment contracts tie PTO to clinical productivity metrics. Taking a holiday off means lost income. For physicians trying to maximize loan repayment or save for a down payment, that lost income matters. So they work.

Read: Transform Your Career with Locum Tenens

The Gift Expectation

Then comes the added layer of family expectations. Because you’re a doctor, relatives assume you can afford extravagant gifts. Because you missed Thanksgiving dinner for a shift, you’re expected to make up for your absence with expensive presents. The Amazon packages become a proxy for presence.

The assumption that physicians are wealthy ignores the reality of debt service, malpractice insurance, and the years spent in training, earning resident salaries while peers in other fields advanced their careers. But try explaining that to an aunt who thinks you should be buying everyone iPads.

The expectation cuts both ways. Show up late to Christmas dinner because of a patient emergency, and you’re the absent family member.

Don’t bring impressive gifts, and you’re the wealthy doctor who doesn’t care enough to spend money on family. It’s a no-win scenario made worse by the fact that you likely spent the morning managing actual life-and-death situations.

The Administration Problem

Here’s where the frustration turns to anger. Hospital administrators, the VPs, and C-suite executives pulling down salaries that would make most physicians envious, enjoy their paid holidays. Their offices close. Their email auto-replies activate. They spend Christmas with family.

The same can’t be said for the physicians keeping their hospitals running. And when staffing gets tight, the administration’s solution isn’t to pay enough to attract adequate coverage. It’s to expect physicians to shoulder the burden.

A colleague worked Christmas alone a few years back. The schedule called for two physicians. Administration couldn’t or wouldn’t pay enough to staff the second position. My friend ended up admitting 20 patients from the ER, managing the workload of two people, without significant additional compensation or bonus.

At some point, overwhelmed and undersupported, she had to draw a line. She told the administration she wouldn’t come in for another shift under those conditions.

You’d think the admin would respond with an apology or a plan to fix staffing. But that’s not the world we live in. They were irritated that a physician would prioritize her own limits over the hospital’s needs.

This is the trap. Physicians are expected to be noble. Self-sacrificing. Available. Meanwhile, the people making staffing decisions and controlling budgets face no such expectations.

They optimize for cost savings and operational efficiency, not for physician wellbeing or patient safety.

The Nobility Trap

Medicine attracts people who want to help others. That impulse gets weaponized. When you raise concerns about unsafe staffing, you’re not being a team player. When you refuse another shift beyond your scheduled obligations, you’re putting yourself before patients.

The nobility of the profession becomes a tool to extract more labor for less compensation.

Hospital systems understand this dynamic perfectly. They know most physicians won’t walk away from patients who need care, even when the system supporting those patients is fundamentally broken.

So they continue to understaff, continue to expect more with less, and continue to prioritize executive compensation over physician support.

The result is predictable. Burnout rates climb. Physicians leave clinical practice. Those who remain grow increasingly resentful of a system that demands their sacrifice while rewarding executives who create the conditions necessitating that sacrifice.

I recall an article from the Wall Street Journal published earlier in the year, about newer doctors questioning the workaholic medical culture, while older doctors disapproved. But even the older generations of doctors admit to burnout impacting their life quality, and by extension, patient care.

Softer Roads: Notes on Physician Job Satisfaction and Survival

The Understaffing Crisis

Understaffing is rarely accidental. It’s almost always a choice. Hospitals could hire more physicians. They could pay enough to ensure adequate holiday coverage. They could structure compensation to reflect the genuine demands of the work.

Instead, they run lean. They rely on physicians’ commitment to patients to paper over systemic inadequacies. They frame reasonable requests for support as unreasonable demands.

Consider the absurdity: a hospital VP who has never touched a patient makes half a million dollars and gets two weeks off for the holidays. The hospitalist keeping the floor running, managing complex patients, making life-and-death decisions, gets scheduled for Christmas and New Year’s because “someone has to be here.”

That someone never seems to be the administrators making these decisions…

The holiday season crystallizes everything dysfunctional about how medicine treats its physicians. The expectation of perpetual availability. The assumption that dedication means accepting poor working conditions. The prioritization of executive compensation over frontline support.

Most professions get time off during holidays. Most employees can plan around major family events with reasonable certainty. Medicine operates differently, not because it must, but because the people running healthcare systems have decided it should.

Of course, hospitals need coverage on holidays. Emergency care doesn’t pause.

The problem is that the coverage burden falls disproportionately on physicians who have minimal power to negotiate better conditions, while those with the power to change the system exempt themselves from its consequences.

This isn’t sustainable. Physicians burning out and leaving practice creates its own crisis. Understaffing begets more understaffing as remaining physicians shoulder increasing loads and decide they can’t continue.

The solution isn’t complicated. Pay physicians appropriately for holiday work. Staff adequately so no one works alone managing impossible patient loads. Give administrators skin in the game by requiring them to experience the conditions they create.

Until then, physicians will continue spending holidays managing patients while missing their families, wondering why their commitment to care is valued so much less than an executive’s vacation time.

The next time someone asks why physicians seem tired or frustrated during the holidays, the answer is simple. They’re at work. Again. While the people who could fix the system are at home with their families.