Skip to content 
You’ve RSVP’d yes. You’ve booked the hotel, bought a pastel dress you’ll never wear again, and Venmo’d $187 to some stranger named “Ashleigh 👰✨” for the bachelorette cabin.
And now? You’re staring at their wedding registry, wondering if you’re a terrible person for filtering by “lowest price.”
Wedding season is here. With it comes the unspoken pressure to give the perfect gift, even if your wallet is still recovering from last month’s wedding in Cancun. Whether you’re an overachieving gift-giver or someone who’s Googled “is $50 too cheap for a wedding gift,” you’re not alone.
But how much should you spend on a wedding gift? And does it really matter if the salad spinner came from the open-box section?
For physicians, you’re in a special kind of hell where the couple and other guests expect you to spend “doctor money” or risk being castigated as tight-fisted, ungenerous, and cheap.
Let’s talk about how to give smart, not spendy, especially when you’ve got financial independence in your sights.
The “rules” (and how no one agrees on them)
If you ask the internet, etiquette experts, or your well-meaning uncle who still sends anniversary cards with a paper check, you’ll get wildly different answers. Here are the most common (and conflicting) “rules” floating around:
- The “cover your plate” rule: You’re supposedly expected to gift the couple the dollar equivalent of what they paid to host you. This is… weird. Unless you’re asking the caterer for an itemized receipt (and what’s next — tipping the DJ?), this metric feels like it belongs in a 2013 bridal forum thread.
- The closeness scale: $50 for coworkers, $100+ for friends, $150+ for close family. This assumes your net worth rises with your proximity to the couple.
- The silent judgment rule: No one will say anything if your gift is $25, but it will look cheap. Especially if everyone else in your same friend “tier” gifted at least $100.
But here’s the secret: There are no real rules. Just vibes. And peer pressure. And a few people who still think an infomercial Vitamix is a reasonable ask.
Reddit threads are full of contradictory takes:
- “I gave $20 and a handwritten note. They still send me Christmas cards.”
- “I was in the wedding party, spent $1,200 on travel and outfits, then got guilted into giving $300.”
- “I gave a Groupon for couples’ salsa lessons. Two years later, they’re still married and still have no rhythm.”
Loose moral threading these stories together?
You might remember what you gifted, but the couple won’t. They’ll remember who showed up for them to share in their happiness.
Is it all just transactional?
Let’s be honest: weddings are weird. They’re part sacred ritual, part Instagram performance, part financial reckoning — especially for guests.
Somewhere between booking flights, buying new shoes, and choosing between a $75 set of glass mixing bowls or a $150 cheese dome, the line between celebration and transaction starts to blur.
And if you’re someone with a solid net worth, or even just the perception of wealth (hi, doctors), you might feel guilted into going big. As if your gift needs to reflect your salary bracket and peacock how well you’re doing, and signal how you’re being generous because you can (and therefore should) be.
But here’s a radical thought: What if your presence, your joy, and your showing up pit-stained in an itchy collar in a summer heat wave is enough?
When my husband and I got married, we were in our early 30s — white-collar professionals with good careers, respectable earnings, and a house we already owned. We weren’t scraping by.
And still, I can barely remember what anyone gave us. It was mostly cash, which was nice but not emotionally memorable. I think close family gave more, but it felt appropriate: within their means, unpressured, and sincere.
The one gift I do remember? The absence of one. My mother attended but brought nothing, not even a card.
What she did bring was a full emotional gift basket: passive aggression, wounded silence, and dramatic side-eyes for anyone who seemed too happy. If emotional martyrdom came boxed and gift-wrapped, it would have been labeled: “To the over-the-hill couple, I hope you get exactly what you deserve.”
All that to say: I don’t remember the dollar amounts. I remember who made us feel loved, and who made us — and our other guests — feel weird.
Should the couple’s wealth affect what you give?
Short answer? Yes.
And it’s perfectly reasonable that it does.
If the couple getting married is already financially well-off — two attending physicians with high earnings, a well-appointed home, and a joint brokerage account — they’re probably not relying on your gift to complete their starter set of cookware.
In cases like these, a modest, meaningful gesture is fitting. Presence over presents, especially when the couple has more financial cushioning than many of their guests.
But if the couple is still in the early stages of their careers — say, medical residents, graduate students, or public servants balancing ambition with modest paychecks, then the equation shifts.
A thoughtful cash gift or something practical can feel more substantial, even if the dollar amount is the same. Not because you need to go big, but because the impact is greater.
You don’t need to overhaul your entire budget based on someone else’s income bracket. But it’s okay to let context shape your choices. Generosity isn’t just about giving more; it’s about giving well.
A quick shorthand:
- Still-in-training professionals or low-salary do-gooders? A little goes a long way. Thoughtful counts more than expensive.
- Dual high-income earners with a honeymoon fund and a registry full of $400+ appliances? Scale it down guilt-free.
- Friends working in service or nonprofit roles? Even a modest gift may feel deeply generous to them and be received with real gratitude.
Giving isn’t about keeping score. But it is about being aware of the landscape. And sometimes the most gracious gifts are the ones that understand who’s truly in need — and who’s already got plenty.
When you’ve already spent a fortune just to be there
Here’s a question that haunts every bridesmaid who’s shelled out $400 for a dress she didn’t choose: Do I still have to give a gift?
Weddings aren’t just expensive for the couple. These days, attending one can mean dropping a casual $1,000+ on flights, hotels, clothes, rental cars, hair appointments, pet-sitting, and 17 rounds of pre-wedding events (all with custom hashtags, of course).
Add “being in the wedding party” to that, and it turns into a full-blown financial commitment you didn’t exactly consent to when you said yes to friendship.
So, do you still owe a gift?
Some people say yes, because you’re in the inner circle. “You’re closer to the couple, so your gift should be more generous.” That logic feels a little off. Shouldn’t the people closest to you be the ones who don’t expect a transaction?
Other people (more chill, more right) say no: If you’re spending hundreds just to show up, that is the gift. Especially if you’re flying across time zones, missing work, or wearing satin in 90° heat.
Here’s the FI-aligned truth: There’s no honor in financial self-immolation for someone else’s love story.
If your presence costs you a lot, your gift can be modest. Or symbolic. Or non-material. Anyone who expects otherwise probably shouldn’t be in your budget — or your life.
Budget baller moves: Giving smart when you spend less
If your love language is frugality, you’re not doomed to hand over a sad $10 Target card and hope for the best. There are so many ways to give thoughtful, generous-seeming gifts without torching your budget — or your dignity.
Here are some fully sanctioned, occasionally scrappy ways to gift like a baller on a budget:
The scuffed gift card special
Buy discounted gift cards from places like Raise, CardCash, or Gift Card Granny. Sure, the $100 Crate & Barrel card you give might’ve cost you $84.82 — but your cousin doesn’t need to know that. As long as it swipes, it slaps.
Of course, this might depend on how well you know the couple. I’ve given scuffed gift cards to family as Christmas presents, adorned in holiday trim. You could always ask the store to let you trade in your dingy card for a brand-new one.
Regifting, but make it classy
Got a duplicate Instant Pot from your birthday? A candle set still in its shrink wrap? As long as it’s unused and unexpired, it’s fair game. Just remove the original gift tag, and maybe throw it in a reusable gift bag so you look eco-conscious instead of suspicious.
Off-registry, but on-theme
Not everything has to be from the registry. Frugal favorites include:
- A couple’s cooking class Groupon (Yes, Groupon is still a thing)
- A nice bottle of wine from the “manager’s special” shelf
- A $25 restaurant gift card paired with a handwritten “date night on us” note
The IKEA-to-Etsy pipeline
Buy a plain cutting board or set of mugs from IKEA, then personalize the gift with a wood burner, paint pen, or stenciled monogram. Suddenly, you’re an artisan, not a cheapskate.
Homemade coupon books
Give the gift of time, skill, or service. Offer to babysit, dog sit, mow their lawn, houseplant-sit during their honeymoon, work their holiday shift, or organize their kitchen cabinets. Make a little “coupon book” that looks sweet and thoughtful.
This isn’t the lame one you gave your mom for Mother’s Day as a kid because you were broke and didn’t want to divert your candy and Pokémon card money to a boxed gift. This is a thoughtful, grown-up version with a loving note, a shared memory, and a card.
It’s especially appreciated if you’re close friends or family — and you actually follow through.
The Venmo vibe
Skip the formality. Just send $50 (or whatever feels right) with a message like, “Congrats! Put this toward your honeymoon margaritas.” No shipping. No wrapping. No cringey Amazon tracking.
Bottom line: Budget like you mean it, gift like you feel it
Weddings are about love. Community. Cake. Not a public ranking of who gave the most expensive blender. And if your relationship with the couple hinges on whether you picked the Le Creuset or the knockoff Dutch oven from last week’s ALDI Finds, you’ve got bigger problems than registry etiquette.
So set a budget before invites start rolling in. Think of it like your holiday spending limit — but for people in formal wear. Decide what feels right for your financial reality and stick to it. Whether it’s $25, $50, or nothing but your sparkling personality and a handwritten card, it’s enough.
There’s no “right” budget or wedding present.
Sometimes, the most generous gift is cash. Sometimes it’s showing up when it costs you something. Sometimes it’s refusing to go broke for people who already have a $10,000, gold-plated, Italian espresso machine.
A good wedding gift doesn’t need to impress, outperform, or keep pace with anyone else’s spreadsheet. It just needs to say: I’m happy for you. I care. I showed up.
Spend what you can. Give what feels sincere. And if anyone tries to turn that into a test of character or generosity, consider that a wedding you can happily skip next time.
