Top 5 Ways I Make Poor Choices With Money
Nobody’s perfect. I’m living, walking, occasionally limping proof of that. I try to do most things the right way, or at least what I think is the right way, but due to some combination of laziness, inexperience, or overconfidence, I often manage to goof things up.
I sometimes make bigger mistakes. I went over the handlebars of my mountain bike at the pump track a couple weeks ago, landing flat on my back. The scars are healing, but I can still tell which finger I stuck in the spinning disc brake rotor 9 months ago, and I just got my e-bike back from the shop after I mangled the rear derailleur and cassette by shortening the chain too much.
My first broken bone (I’ve had quite a few) was also a bike’s fault. Or the jump’s fault. Or maybe, just possibly, 8-year old me’s fault. I guess I’ve made a few poor choices while on or in close proximity of bicycles.
When it comes to money, though, I usually make better choices.
The choices I’ve made put me in a position to afford an early retirement before my fortieth birthday. I’ve opted to work part-time instead while plotting my exit strategy that will have me free as a bird well before my 45th birthday.
But even with money, I have made and continue to make choices that many would consider suboptimal. These are my top five money mistakes.
Top 5 Ways I Make Poor Choices With Money
1. I carry no mortgage.
We acquired our current home in 2013 when interest rates were near all-time lows. At the time, conventional wisdom would suggest that we would likely come out ahead by taking out a mortgage loan and remaining fully invested in the stock market.
Hindsight shows just how right conventional wisdom turned out to be. Since November of 2013, when we sold some mutual funds to come up with the cash for our house, the S&P 500 (with dividends reinvested) has gone up about 68%. Conventional wisdom, how right you were.
In spite of the math, I can’t say I regret these decisions. While I did miss out on some gains, real estate accounts less than 15% of our net worth, so it wasn’t a make or break deal. And while hindsight is 20 / 20, had the market taken a turn for the worse instead, we would have looked like visionaries.
I can say it does feel great to be truly debt-free and to be a rare “homeowner” who actually owns a home.
2. I spend from our Health Savings Account (HSA).
Once again, the math favors growing an HSA as much as possible as the Biglaw Investor recently pointed out. The optimal way to use an HSA is to invest as much as allowed each year, track health care spending, save and scan every receipt, allow the HSA balance to compound tax-free, and decades from now, withdraw a lump sum equal to the total of all those receipts.
I understand why that’s best. I actually adopted this strategy for a couple years, and I found it to be a royal pain in the rear.
I don’t like scanning receipts and entering each one into a spreadsheet, saving the paper receipts elsewhere to cash in at some far away date. It’s a lot of effort for a sliver of optimization.
A lot can change between now and that later date, including the tax code or how it’s interpreted. I think it is pretty cut and dry as written, but the bigger risk is probably me. What if I’m no longer around at that yet-to-be-determined future date? Or I’m around but on my next trip over the handlebars, I land on my head and don’t know an HSA from an IHOP.
If we spend $5,000 from the HSA annually, and we look at that as shifting money from a tax-advantaged account to a taxable brokerage account, that $5,000 will be subject to a tax drag of about a half percent while working. That’s $25 per year and after I retire, tax drag could be next to nothing. To me, it’s not worth the hassle.
There is one smart play that I am making with the HSA. I never put any expense directly on the debit card that came with the account. I always charge our expenses to a credit card with excellent travel or cash back rewards. I then reimburse myself from the HSA; this nets me 1% to 2% or more, besting that smaller tax drag, and is totally worth the hassle.
3. We have a second home (with plans for a third).
Remember what The White Coat Investor said? One House, One Spouse, One Job. I’ve got the one spouse thing figured out, but have not done so well with the other two directives.
I’ve described in the past how our second home is one of our best investments. When you can pick one up at auction, it’s possible to get a heck of a deal, which we most certainly did.
It does cost money, though. We’ve got property taxes, association dues, utilities to pay, and we make the 10-plus hour drive each way four to six times a year (just completed one yesterday and wrote this post on the way). There’s also the opportunity cost of having cash sunk into a property that could otherwise be invested in the stock marke.
I’m not quite as optimistic as he is regarding the true value of the land, and yes, we’re appealing that assessment.
Eventually, we plan to make the planned third home our primary home, letting go of the second and the first, and we’ll be back to one house for the first time in over ten years.
Having a second home hasn’t made us wealthier, but it has given us the opportunity to spend more time with my wife’s family without taking over their homes (although we do that, too) and brings us close to friends we made when living nearby. Again, with this money mistake, I have no regrets.
4. We are not itemizing deductions.
Another first. At least for the first time in more than ten years, we are not itemizing deductions in 2018.
We obviously have no mortgage interest to deduct. Our combined property tax and state income tax deduction is limited to $10,000. The vast majority of our donations come from our donor-advised fund (DAF), and we’ve already collected the tax deduction on those.
With a $24,000 standard deduction for joint filers, we’re about $14,000 shy of having enough deductions to itemize. We continue to donate some items we no longer need to the Salvation Army or Goodwill, but I’d be hard-pressed to come up with $1,400 in receipts for the year, let alone $14,000.
I’m not saying we’ll never itemize again, but it makes no sense to do so in our current situation after the latest tax reform. If this site continues to be profitable, I’ll eventually be in a position to donate again to our donor advised fund, and I’ll probably wait to make another six-figure donation. The first $14,000 donated won’t receive any preferential tax treatment.
Am I really doing the wrong thing with money here? Not exactly. If you are planning to take the standard deduction, you might as well not have almost $24,000 in deductions (or $12,000 for single filers. This is where the bunching of deductions can make sense, which is essentially what we do with our DAF.
5. I am retiring early.
Make no mistake; this is a money mistake. A $10 Million mistake. And a mistake I’m happy to make.
I could probably continue as an anesthesiologist for another 25 years if I really had the desire. And if the future looks anything like the past, I could probably average $400,000 a year. $10 Million is a lot to walk away from.
I’ve gone into detail as to why I want to retire early and why I chose not to pursue the $10 Million dream. The closer I get to making early retirement my reality, the more I dwell on whether or not this is the path I want to choose. I’m not saying I’m questioning the decision. I am asking questions, but the answers continue to confirm this as the choice I’m ready to make.
I’m ready to sleep more, stress less, travel longer and farther, and to finally be in charge of where and how I spend my days.
I do feel I’ve had a great, albeit short, career as an anesthesiologist. I believe it has been the best doctor job for me. The job has its perks, but one of those perks is not autonomy. I spend my workday running from one place to another to meet the needs of many patients, surgeons, and nurses. I have no say in what happens or when. I’m at the mercy of the schedule and the unscheduled emergencies.
Of course, I may miss it. I know I’ll miss some aspects and I’m leaving the door open just a crack by keeping my licensure and certifications for a year or two after I’m done.
I’m also not walking away from earning money entirely. While I am donating half my profits from this enterprise, I do keep the other half, and that’s getting to be a decent sum. I don’t publish the details here, but I do share them with my e-mail subscribers in a quarterly progress note, and we’re due for another of those next weekend. Sign up for details, and you can unsubscribe any time.
I also offer a weekly e-mail subscription if you don’t want an e-mail with each new post. You’ll still get the quarterly newsletter, too.
Tell me about your money mistakes. Do you intentionally do the wrong thing (or suboptimal thing) with your money? I’ll see you in the comments.